I don't think there is. I wholeheartedly agree with the prior sentiment. Way too much of peoples lives are spent on shit that does not really matter. As a people we have overcomplicated the shit out of everything to such a degree it's disgusting. And it's all based on greed. Optimize this structure to pay the least tax, optimize your income into this and that so it magically makes more money. Meanwhile those without any real money can't take advantage of any of that kind of stuff. Yeah, really fair!
Not everyone subscribes to the financial bullshit the wealth class has created.
Do you agree with the premise that it would be incredible dumb and dangerous not to structure their business into a legal limited liability company?
Do you agree that the accounting and tax handling is best left to professionals because it can be complicated and because you trade a little bit of money for the peace of mind that you’re following the rules and more free time?
If you agree with those two points, then the act of paying out the profits as a dividend instead of a salary rolls out pretty much for free. Because it’s not some hard to set up tax avoidance construction, it’s the norm.
The fact of the matter is I'm not saying "don't use a professional". I'm against the very concept of how convoluted everything is in this world- and nearly everything is created in ways that benefit people who make up let's say the top 15% of earners.
I'm not oblivious to any of these things, I have an econ, accounting & M.S. finance degree. I have a CPA (never practiced).
And you know what? I see this shit all the time in my line of work. I've been lucky enough to do more of the technology/programming side of the industry I'm in so I don't kill myself on the meaningless garbage that the people I'm creating stuff for actually do.. but I see this shit all the time.
Structures or laws being set up constantly to avoid tax that your normal person has absolutely no way to use. Self employed people setting up S-Corps so they don't have to pay into social security because they will be rich enough they don't need it themselves so why pay into the system to help others. People in other countries setting up US structures so they can pay a lower tax rate here than their home country while they get to reap all the benefits. LLCs being set up in delaware so you don't have to pay state taxes when one could easily argue you operate there if anyone checked. People throwing money into dividend paying stocks just because of a low tax. Reducing long term capital gains to stupidly low tax levels.
I mean I can go on and on. Your average person GETS ALMOST NONE OF THESE BENEFITS.
I'm not saying all of the stuff is bad or not needed. But the vast majority is set up so people who already make way more than the average person don't have to pay their fair share.
So look- I'm more being general here. I'm not specifically talking about this case as much as I'm just bitching about how the world works. It just disgusts me at this point. What one calls "optimization", at this point in my life I call it taking advantage.
The tax code is structured the way it is for a reason. It’s not there to be exploited. It’s there to be followed. DF is a business and labor of love for the two owners. One which generates revenue and is clearly above board. There is nothing wrong with taking dividends as the business becomes more valuable rather than increasing salary. And it’s not some mega tax loophole for the wealthy. By any measure these two aren’t wealthy. It takes 30 min with an accountant it doesn't consume your life and waste time and sap energy to be on top of your books…
They don't have a lump 7MM sitting around and are most certainly not set for life. Someone else did the math and it comes out to 100k per person per year after taxes and fees. Do you want to reassess?
I’m sure you’ll agree that it’d be mindblowingly dumb to not set some kind of company for a bunch of reasons? (Eg limited liability)
And that you best leave accounting and tax filings to professionals so that you can spend your precious time on something you love instead?
OP’s suggestion automatically flows from that…