Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Indeed.

But the Fire Emblem sprites were redrawn with details from each of the characters in the game. Amelia from FE8 for example, was the only blonde female paladin, and her long-blonde hair would blow in the wind during her critical hit animation.

The animations were incredibly personalized to the characters, a true feat for a game with several dozen playable characters (and random mooks to KO).

In contrast, the 3D Art of FE:Awakening is clearly built off of recycled bone animations across multiple units. Furthermore, they were mostly recycled from FE9 and FE10.

The level of effort needed to create the 2D sprites is clearly much higher than the level of effort for FE:Awakening's animations.



Sigh, the "benefits" of industrialisation and new tech. Fortunately I hope that 2d or 3d pros and cons are known and mastered enough so people can go back to produce artful games.

Similarly to movies, early 2K era movies were speaking too much of CGI, now SFX aren't attractive anymore, you got to give density.

ps: about the level of effort, I think it's not fair, 3d modeling and animating was hard, but more than that it made people focus on low level details rather than 'impressionist' ones. You had to care about all angles and didn't have time nor knowledge on what made a good animation. Same goes for old animations.


Arc System Works is doing a good job actually with their 3D style in Guilty Gear Xrd. Nintendo's Super Smash Bros. is also quite excellent 3D Artwork.

As is whatever the heck this is from: http://kotaku.com/sorry-yes-animation-is-also-games-art-1699...

So solid, good 3D art exists, and is around. Gears of War also deserves a mention.


True, I didn't want to dismiss good 3d artwork.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: