Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Quoting from the article:

    Part of the problem is that none of these articles were
    co-written by a Liberian scientist. The investigators
    collected their samples, returned home and published
    the startling results in European medical journals.
    Few Liberians were then trained in laboratory or
    epidemiological methods. Even today, downloading one
    of the papers would cost a physician here $45, about
    half a week’s salary.


On the flip side, even Liberia's ministry of health (see author's credentials) could afford the $45, then disseminate to the clinics.

// Disclaimer: I lived and worked in Cameroon in the 80s, writing software for tracking and publishing data for various govt ministries.


Academic here. There is no reason why these articles should have to cost $45. Academics have to publish in name-brand journals to get recognized, and these high prices are pure rent-seeking on behalf of the publishers.


publishers need to make money too. i also dislike this anti 'rent-seeking' culture. if there is no reason for it to cost that much, start your own publishing company and give out the materials for free (or some lower price).


> start your own publishing company and give out the materials for free

There are many people that are moving exactly to this. As ever, the problem is that the market is not perfectly fluid and things like academic cultural biases, impressions of prestige, etc often do not follow the most efficient contours. Posts like the GP's are called for precisely because they call attention to this and try to shift perception.


Yep, that's what the whole Open Access movement is about, and it is making good progress.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: