Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is a great set, but a request to Joey:

There are two conflicting implementations of a parallel utility. And from what I can tell, the GNU parallel utility is much more useful than the one in moreutils. Which meant that when I was 1) doing processing which benefited greatly from parallelization and 2) found that the moreutils version wasn't doing what I wanted nor could I figure out how to make it do so (compounded by confusion over online searched providing GNU parallels syntax which didn't work), I had to remove the entire moreutils set to install GNU parallels under Debian.

The two versions aren't even a candidate for /etc/alternatives resolution as the commandline syntax and behavior differs.

Either a name change or refactoring to a different package for the 'parallel' utility would avoid much of this.

And I'd really like to see numutils packaged.

Also: 'unsort': sort -R | --random-sort

(using GNU coreutils 8.23)

(I'm not familiar with a seed-based randomized sorting utility though.)




I'm familiar with that.

Joey's apparent resistance to simply splitting out 'parallel' to its own package is ... disappointing. His final comment (regarding other utilities in upstream and switches) is non sequiturs and red herrings.


Welcome to Debian politics.

Where boneheads like Joey get to block trivial fixes for decades (5 years and counting in this case). The project really needs a better process to terminate 'lame' maintainers.


Just for completeness https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=518696 Had parallel been packaged at that time (Mar 2009), it would have pre-empted the parallel in moreutils (which was added June 2009).


My point is that Joey is not in general a bonehead. That's part of what makes this all the more disappointing.

He's no longer the package maintainer, which should make the split more viable.


The last update on that old bug was in 2012.

This is the relevant current bug on the matter against moreutils: https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=718816


> And I'd really like to see numutils packaged.

https://packages.debian.org/sid/num-utils




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: