Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

By the description it seems like they have reduced the energy so that not only intermolecular energy is reduced (or somehow stop), but also it reduces interatomic energy some how. Is this possible? It´s there another atomic absolute zero still to be discovered beyond 0K?

I´m have no idea about physics, so surely what I say doesn´t make sense.



To expand on what avoid3d said:

You can make a plot of entropy vs. energy of a system. Further, you can calculate the derivative (slope) of that plot and give it a name. You could also calculate the quantity 1/slope and give that a name, too--and the name we give it is "temperature." So, the temperature of the system is negative any time the slope of entropy vs. energy is negative.

How do we get a negative slope? We need to find a place where entropy decreases when energy is added to the system. Entropy is proportional to the natural log of something called the "partition function (see below)." That means we need to find a place where partition function has a negative slope.

The partition function tells us essentially "how many distinct ways can we arrange (store) a given amount of energy in this system?" For almost all macroscopic systems, there are a greater number of ways to rearrange the system each time a unit of energy is added. However, it is possible to construct a system where adding a unit of energy actually restricts the number of ways you can arrange the system. And that is the basis for negative temperature.


The reason that negative temperatures are hard to explain is that the definition of temperature in the sense used by physicists is not very accessible.

It has to do with how much a certain property of a system (object) changes when you add a certain quantity of heat energy.

In certain edge cases adding energy makes this quantity change in the opposite to usual way and therefore the temperature is negative.


I´ve been reading the negative temperature link, I understand that you reduce entropy reducing energy, till a point, where you start "holding" the molecules down adding energy (I don´t know if that makes sense).

But still is there a way that you could start affecting the forces inside the atom this way?. Or then we are talking about something different?.


This is really on the edge if where I don't know what I'm talking about anymore but I would think not.

The forces holding atoms together and the energies associated with changing those forces are far larger than the amounts that are presented in this study.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: