Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If we gave everyone a billion dollars except you, does it impoverish you in anyway? I think so.

I wrote this article because the tech scene is so disconnected from where it started.



Does every startup have to be immediately beneficial to the consumer? What if someone like Procter & Gamble has a bigger R&D budget to dedicate to some miracle spray like Febreze only after they've switched to something like cloud-based vendor billing, which allowed them to save a lot?

Is cloud-based vendor billing society-changing? Probably not. Do they help out older companies and new startups entering the field by taking care of something nobody wanted to focus on? Probably yes.


It all started with Shockly (sp?) & Co. building better bombs. The first disruption was putting the transistor in something as stupid as a radio. Seems to me that society's always been more interested in the stupid consumer application of impressive technology.


Radios are "stupid"?

I can assure you that people who lived in remote areas found radios that could run off batteries for extended periods very useful indeed (for that matter, people who live in remote areas now find them useful).


Yes, through inflation. But your article never mentions that.

If you mentioned inflation, someone would point that inflation has been very low for the past few years.


How so, exactly? By having less money than others? Millionaires are impoverished if you equate it with inequality.


This is actually one of those catch 22's of wealth: if you're in the 50% you probably feel better about your money than you do if you're in the 2% or -- even worse -- the bottom of the 1%. The reason is that the 49% is almost exactly like you. They make a few bucks more than you do but it's not meaningful (i.e. you both have exactly the same standard of living). Now, if you belong to the 2%, you are an order of magnitude "poorer" than the 1%. If you just made it to the 1%, you are a couple of orders of magnitude "poorer" than the 0.1%. And, those differences are meaningful.

It's really one of the sadder aspects of human nature. No one can just enjoy how good they have it. We always have to grade ourselves on a curve. Shit, if I compare my life to Rockefeller or JP Morgan, I have it so much better in so many ways. But, no one over feels bad for Rockefeller because that sucker lived before the internet.


Inflation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: