Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

EU regulators, the people who brought us lead-free solder, are going to love the "plumbate" part. It might as well be plutonium.


You're not one of those RoHS deniers are you? I hate to break it to you, but EVERYTHING made in the last ten years is made with lead-free solder and ta-da: it all works perfectly well.


Yes ,everything

..except automotive, agricultural, aviation, health and so on basically anything that is even remotely critical is exempt.


Over the past few years, pretty much everything critical has been built with standard SnPb solder under various RoHS exemptions. Most of those exemptions have recently expired or are expiring soon. It is far too soon to pat yourself on the back over the apparent absence of adverse consequences.


Yes, they've figured it out now. There was an ugly transition period though.


Agreed, but I'd add that the transition period coincided with the switch to water based flux processes, and the headlong rush to China. All of those things involved their own sets of birthing pains.


Lead is a poison; that's not news.

The issue is whether solar panels containing lead are going to be the same as solder containing lead. I'm going to go with "no, not exactly" as solder is an OTC consumable that gets thrown around during DIY, fragments dropped on the floor where pets and toddlers can chew on them, it gets heated and inhaled, etc.

Solar panels are not quite the same. No doubt lead inside the sealed unit will cause implications for safe disposal; but then lots of things have special disposal, e.g. batteries.


DIY people can still get ordinary SnPb solder by the kilo. Here's a bar that contains 500g of pure lead: http://media.digikey.com/Photos/Kester%20Photos/04-6337-0050...

It's only $44, shipped! It's enough lead to measurably lower the IQ of ten million infants.

The idea that out-of-control EU regulators prevent anyone, individual or industry, from acquiring and using elemental lead products is just another libertarian bugaboo that routinely pops up here on HN.


Do you have any pointers to studies that indicate that anyone -- child or otherwise -- has ever absorbed a significant quantity of lead from solder?


I'll take that as a "No."


I guess you can isolate the cells in a clear glass sandwich.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: