Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm sure Apple will roll something out in the coming years. Now that just anyone can easily AI themselves into a picture in front of the Eiffel tower, they'll want a feature that will let their users prove that they _really_ took that photo in front of the Eiffel tower (since to a lot of people sharing that you're on a Paris vacation is the point, more than the particular photo).

I bet it will be called "Real Photos" or something like that, and the pictures will be signed by the camera hardware. Then iMessage will put a special border around it or something, so that when people share the photos with other Apple users they can prove that it was a real photo taken with their phone's camera.



Does anyone other than you actually care about your vacation photos?

There used to be a joke about people who did slideshows (on an actual slide projector) of their vacation photos at parties.


This exists, the standard is called C2PA, Google added support for it in the Pixel 10. I was surprised and disappointed that Apple didn’t add support for it in the most recent iPhone! A few physical cameras are starting to support it too (https://yawnbox.eu/blog/c2pa-camera/)


How would this stop people from using their iPhone to take pictures of AI generated images?

> a real photo taken with their phone's camera

How "real" are iPhone photos? They're also computationally generated, not just the light that came through the lens.

Even without any other post-processing, iPhones generate gibberish text when attempting to sharpen blurry images, they delete actual textures and replace them with smooth, smeared surfaces that look like a watercolor or oil paintings, and combine data from multiple frames to give dogs five legs.


Don’t be a pedant. You know very well there is a big different between a photo taken on an iPhone and a photo edited with Nano Banana.


this already exists. its called 35mm film camera.


Can't wait for a machine printing images on film by exposing it with a laser.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: