Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> am always puzzled that people think other people believe the purpose of law and order is "deterrent"...have you ever met anyone who says this?

………yes, many of them. Do you talk to real people about prison policy a lot?

> if you let them out they will commit crimes

I guess not, since we have plenty of evidence that 75yo men with one leg and cancer are at 0% risk of recidivism, and yet they’re still locked up.



Yes, PG in political science and I have worked in policy research. How about you?

The probability of committing a crime is significantly higher if you have committed a crime before. This is constant in every society that doesn't put criminals in jail. You seem to be suggesting some interesting new theory that not having a leg is really what everyone should care about...if you were reading someone else say this would you take this seriously? No, a tiny proportion commit the majority of crime, serious crime in countries like the US is almost all committed by 1% of the population. The solution is simple: put them in jail, crime disappears.

Violent crime is a choice.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: