Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How is it known, this is not propaganda or an embellishment of a situation ...?


surely it can be; why don't israel let journalists to enter gaza, so that many eyes will be there to see what is going on actually...

oh I think I know why, everyone knows why...


One data point is not enough to draw a line. But if you have two, three, dozens of data point... And the line points to the same thing over and over again.


This man is definitely not the only one who has come forward. At want point to do you actually take multiple witnesses and believe them?

Many aid agencies and other sources on the ground have also verified many of the claims, when journalists can't (considering they've been banned from entering). Are all the aid agencies lying too?

And sometimes, just sometimes, in this world of AI now, video evidence is accurate.

The world is imperfect, and so we go with the balance of probabilities.

And I'll confirm for you. There's a murderous genocide taking place.


How do you know that Hamas is not involved in these cases? You can not.

Also a high percentage of the said 50,000 killed would have to be Hamas terrorists.

Also, Hamas would be working overtime to make this new way of food distribution to fail.

Gaza people would not want to blame Hamas at ALL, since Hamas kills people who criticize them. This has happened in Past

In fact it is reported Hamas told Gaza people not to get food from the new distrubution places.

Hamas would also have to be guilty of genocide. In fact they have previously stated this in writing. Hamas is prepared to sacrifice Gaza people. Also Hamas committed genocide on October 7th


You appear to have ignored everything I said. I hope you don't mind if I return the favour.

I'll just end by saying that, to me, Israels actions in terms of Gaza over the last 2 years mean I do not differentiate those who carry out the actions from Nazi's (dictionary definitions). And that applies to those who support those actions. I've worded this carefully so you know that I do not refer to all Israeli's, because I don't. But it probably applies to you.


Ha - gets downvoted but with no comment - of how it is known or not. Their would be propaganda and embellishment from both sides.

About sides making mistakes in war - such in WCK World Central Kitchen deaths - I recall that was US claim in the deaths in about the "collateral murder" video ( about 2010 ??) from WikiLeaks - it was a mistake - the photographers telephoto lens looked like a rocket launcher?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: