Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> So all counties with strong border policies are racist? That’s preposterous.

Your response is a straw man. Be better.

FWIW I don’t agree with OP in that there isn’t a single cause, but racism definitely plays a role.



Doesn't seem like a straw man to me. It's an extension of the unsupported claim that the cause for the action is racism. False equivalence perhaps. But I think the problem is that "The cause for the action is racism" doesn't actually contain an argument at all. It's just an unfounded opinion.

And then "Anything else is denial" shows a myopic, closed minded viewpoint, suggesting any further discussion would be pointless. As is most internet chatter on this type of matter.


I think we have a different interpretation of what a straw man fallacy is.

The person I was replying to refuted an argument that GP did not make. And one that was arguably weaker and more difficult to defend.

That’s my understanding of what the strawman fallacy is. What’s yours?

> But I think the problem is that "The cause for the action is racism" doesn't actually contain an argument at all.

Yeah this is an oversimplification and not really an actionable one. But there’s an argument buried in there and it’s not wrong. The current administration plays on existing racist and xenophobic undertones to drum up support. It’s all fear based rhetoric.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: