Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Are you trying to make a career of misunderstanding my replies? Or am I just really that bad at writing?

No, I'm just looking past the florid language. You've literally said that regulation is useless because it's either too late or too far.

There's probably some fantastical perfect moment when regulation is just right, but it will never come because there will always be people for whom regulation is either too late, or too far.

> _People_, potential buyers, are _supposed_ to demand sensible things from companies. By voting with their money. Does that not work anymore?

It has never worked. At least not to the extent people pretend it's working.



No, what I said is that were I to be interested in buying a Volvo, I would've gone to the dealership to see it, and upon finding out that some functionality is available only if I login with my Google account, would tell the dealer that that's a dealbreaker and walk out.

If the car market is such that all car manufacturers are in a way colluding with Google to require such login, that's different and should already be regulated (if not, regulate). But if another manufacturer will sell me what I want, I fail to see the issue for me as a consumer.

But, I'm not against regulation per se (as you've accused me of), so I'm not ready to die on this hill :) You may be right after all.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: