The "community notes" on twitter have just become another ideology battle ground, if you have seen them from the contributor side of things.
Another major issue with them is they take to long to materialize, and by the time the note is added, most of the views on opinion formation has already happened.
I think a better option is to have both systems (professional and from the user base), and multiple groups of each, all in competition with each other. Then let users decide which one(s) they want to have in their feed.
This is how ATProto/Bluesky approaches the problem
Another major issue with them is they take to long to materialize, and by the time the note is added, most of the views on opinion formation has already happened.
I think a better option is to have both systems (professional and from the user base), and multiple groups of each, all in competition with each other. Then let users decide which one(s) they want to have in their feed.
This is how ATProto/Bluesky approaches the problem
https://bsky.social/about/blog/03-12-2024-stackable-moderati...
(notes are an extension the labeller concept)