Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No man that gets a bonus when people that could be saved die is an innocent man


HN is quite a glass house. Moralizing then back to selling peoples data and ensuring warehouse workers suffer and get our kids get addicted to doomscrolling, while selling people more shit they don't need. Then use that money to push up house prices.


What makes you think that people supporting the exit of evil CEOs also support evil CEOs selling people's data?


You don't think there's a single person on here celebrating this killing who also worked at Facebook, Google, or the like at any point in their lives?


I'm sure there are people here who have caused a lot of harm to others while working at amazon or google or facebook. Probably even a few who should be behind bars. It's possible that some of them were happy to hear that the CEO was killed. I doubt it's most of us though.

There's a lot of space between "knowingly kills people for profit" and "collects user data from an app/works on a manipulative algorithm" which could make it easy for some people to pretend that they aren't doing "real" harm or to believe that the CEO was a "real problem" while they personally aren't.

I hope that the more people are held accountable for what they do (regardless of how that happens) it'll force others to do some self-reflection even if only out of a sense of self-preservation, but I'd be careful about generalizing too much. The people posting here are a pretty diverse lot, and you can find hypocrisy in any sufficiently large group. I wouldn't call HN a "glass house" but it's got a few big windows.


As always, there is a cost benefit analysis one must perform when doing anything, including administering healthcare treatment. Is it worth $40M in costs to save a 94 year old from death today when the expected payoff is 2 more months of life?

I'm all for changing the system, but this action likely won't do that.


Literally every single one of us is guilty, then. You could personally do something today that would save a life, instead of what you'll actually do. That doesn't make you guilty of anything, though.


> Literally every single one of us is guilty, then

Yes, all of "us" doing it industrial scale and getting paid for it are guilty. Not me, but maybe you.


I am not, as I'm sure you guessed, the CEO of a healthcare corporation. I'm probably as equally guilty as you are, in your own terms.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: