Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The smokes don’t seem like that big of a deal but the fire seems like it is a complete disaster for fairness. That’s actually pretty horrific - the other contestants out there working and suffering their asses off to survive and he gave a huge leg up to arbitrary competitors? I should hope he got in serious trouble - can you imagine an official in a sports competition casually messing with the game w/ $1M on the line???


I regret to say that the show is probably only concerned with the appearance of fairness, as viewed by edited footage post-hoc. Not the experience of the contestants so much.

For example, I previously believed the contestants to be truly alone, in that each potential encounter with bears would be hugely risky. But now I know that was a minimal risk because a bodyguard was close enough to intervene, and was probably monitoring grizzly activity in the area.

The mental changes that happen to a contestant when they can even see someone nearby kind of invalidates the whole premise a little.


I think you’re thinking this show is a lot more real than it actually is. It is scripted reality TV, not serious, not real.

He said he and the camera crew talked to the contestants all the time, despite them being shown to be “alone”

I think he said he gave fire to people that already had it anyway and theirs just went out.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: