Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I disagree, I believe your perspective is short-sighted. If you really think what makes a movie "impactful" is the music, ambience, and script then I don't think you have much media literacy.

It's no more ridiculous than saying what makes a painting impactful is the brush strokes. But if I copy Picasso's work stroke for stroke, why am I not Picasso? After all, the dumbass paints like a child, admittedly! How could someone like him ever be considered a great painter?



You forget that there's a human behind the prompt, stitching frames and dialogue together.


If they are stitching then I would consider that a form of art.

However, merely describing something is not doing the thing. Otherwise, the business analysists at my company would be software engineers. No, I make the software, and they describe it.

The end-goal here is humanless automation, no? Then I'm not sure your assumption holds up. If there's no human, I question the value.


> If there's no human, I question the value.

You may question the value but if it’s anything like rugs you won’t be in the majority. People pay a significant premium for artisanal handmade rugs but that being said, more than 95% of the rugs people use are machine made because they’re essentially indistinguishable from a handmade one and are much, much cheaper and just as functional.


No I don't think it'll be anything like rugs




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: