Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Simple - if you restrict the software industry, the US loses to China or any other country that doesn’t give a damn. And unless you censor the internet, there’s absolutely no way to prevent illicit software from crossing the border.

Would a business get in trouble for using it? Sure. But if all the businesses in your country are at a competitive disadvantage because the competition is so much brighter elsewhere, and that “sloppy constructed” software is allowing international competition to have greater productivity and efficiency, your country is hosed. Under your own theory, imagine if the US was stuck with ~2007 technology while China was in 2024. The tradeoff would be horrific - like, Taiwan might not exist right now, horrific.

Regulating software right now would kill the US competitive advantage. It narrows every year - that would do it overnight. The US right now literally cannot afford to regulate software. The EU, which can afford it, is already watching talent leaving.

There’s also the problem of the hundreds of billions of lines of code written before regulations running in production at this very moment. There are not enough programmers on earth that could rewrite it all to spec, even if they had decades. Does Google just get a free grandfathered-in pass then, but startups don’t?



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: