Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Remote work is the best thing to happen to families in decades (erikhoel.substack.com)
120 points by jger15 on Jan 27, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 29 comments


I did some napkin math on saved time.

commute: So my "commute" is only 5 minutes, yes a short walk from home. But still, I work 240 days a year, so that's 240 * 5 min * 2 = 2400 minutes saved, or 40 hours a year. A full workweek! Imagine if my commute was 30 minutes each way? That would come to 240 hours / year, or 6 full workweeks - just getting to and from work. After just over 8 years, you've spent a full year on travel. Insane.

transportation: I walk or bike to work, so no big deal for me - but my collogue has a 1 hour commute each way, around 44 miles. That's 88 miles of driving every day. When he switched form gas to EV vehicle, he saved a bit over $5k in fuel, as he could charge for free at work. But you still have repairs, maintenance and what not. Those that drive ICE vehicles can save tens of thousands in fuel costs by working remote from home.

chores and housework: I was amazed how much I got done at home during lunch. Spent 5-10 mins eating, then do whatever needs to be done in the house. The weekends got much more freed up.

I'm probably forgetting some points.


I do creative work. Doing house chores in between work often put my mind into an idyllic state and it gives me flowing ideas, akin to when we procrastinate.


People disapproving of remote work is so illogical. If the work can be done remotely as done effectively as IRL and the people are happier remote or hybrid, let them do that.


Same the other way. I preferred working in the office. WFH is isolating and often inefficient. Video calls just aren’t as good as face to face interactions. But most companies seem to have not renewed the lease on their offices so it’s becoming less of an available option.


> Video calls just aren’t as good as face to face interactions.

Hard disagree. You state it like it's a fact, but it's not. It's an opinion.

Especially for programmers a remote meeting is often better. For example, 6 engineers can meet for an impromptu meeting, someone shares their screen, all 6 people can see the shared screen clearly, all 6 people can point at things on the person's screen, all 6 people can interactively sketch ideas at the same time on the same virtual whiteboard, everyone can keep their own copy of the code open and readable while seeing the shared screen right next to it, etc. There's a lot of good things about this that cannot be replicated in person.


Hybrid can solve this, at our group meetings (physical science, not SWE) we’ll sometimes all have laptops up at the conference table to collaborate on a document or whatever. We have a large physical screen that I think is better than sharing a screen in video chat.

Remote is ok, but as an introvert I sometimes find it harder to get a word in edgewise, and I already sometimes struggle with that during in person meetings. That and I feel like IRL conversations are somehow better for unstructured/lateral/creative thinking


I have never encountered this supposed inefficiency of working from home, especially when you add in the many hours wasted commuting.

I get that many people use the office as a primary source of socialization, others aren't able to communicate online effectively, and yet others like wasting time in meetings instead of working.

It's obnoxious that those folk get priority, and the rest of us are forced to lose hours and hours our lives to needless commuting, and forced to have much worse working environments - the many varying approaches to "employees are livestock"/"open plan" have been demonstrated in every single study to be aggressively bad for productivity.

Finally, by not having to go to the office I'm not being exposed constantly to asshole coworkers who come into the office while sick, or when they have clearly sick family members. One of the greatest things in the work from home experience of the few years is not catching various plagues from coworkers. I went multiple years without so much as a cold.

Now I get to have forced exposure to those same coworkers that came in while sick in the past, so I have no trust that those who get covid won't come to the office to spread that plague around either.

Seriously I'm fine if you want to waste time commuting and getting sick if you need the office to socialize, or if you aren't able to communicate effectively online. I just don't understand why everyone else should have their lives made worse just to support you.


The single genuine inefficiency of working from home is that it exposes a person's lack of discipline. They become more productive when all distractions are removed so they're forced to focus on one task at the detriment of everything else.

This turns into a form of self torture though, since the office is ripe with distractions that they have to power through to get their tasks done. But because they're not afforded the luxury of getting distracted by things they'd like, and they hate the office distractions, they'd rather be doing work. The overall experience is shitty in the end but at least they're getting some work done.

It sucks for the rest of us though, because now the self flagellation needs to be extended and we're all victims of presumption. "Since I can't get work done at home, then surely others can't as well! They're just sitting at home doing nothing, like I would be doing! Everyone needs to come back to the office now!"

Other than that, WFH was genuinely sucky for people with small children, because daycares were also closed during peak covid.


One wonders if that’s why there’s seemingly been an explosion on ADHD (self-)diagnoses lately.

Not even saying those diagnoses are wrong. It’s just the additional self-discipline requirements imposed by WFH exposed what was already there.


I suspect the explosion of ADHD, is an explosion of people complaining about how the DEA has decided that while mass over prescription of Oxy is fine, ADHD meds should be heavily restricted because that isn't profitable.

Seriously: every person I have learned has ADHD recently, I have learned because the DEA screwing with the availability of their prescribed medication.


While I do think more attention needs to be paid towards overmedication, I think plenty of people now are experiencing ADHD-like symptoms, whether from having the disorder itself, or perhaps continuous digital stimulation coupled with UX patterns designed to drive further stimulation will inherently create ADHD-like behavior.


I mean "I have learned that they have ADHD, because they have been complaining that they have suddenly been unable to get medication they've been on for years".


ADHD treatment is very ADHD-hostile. This must change.


> The single genuine inefficiency of working from home is that it exposes a person's lack of discipline. They become more productive when all distractions are removed so they're forced to focus on one task at the detriment of everything else.

If offices surround people with distractions that pull them away from their work, isn't that the fault of the office?

People shouldn't have to have monk-like discipline to focus on a task while everyone around them is trying to pull them away from it.

It's not a discipline failure that offices are not set up to be productive in.


I find context matters with WFH/WIO and the balance comes, for me, when it's creative brainstorming or anything that requires a hands on, in the office is great but outside of that the office can be super distracting away from the core work.

It really depends though on what type of role and personalities are coming together and I'm hopeful there will be a more innovative culture going forward.


People forget about the scourge of the open office before the pandemic. Would be nice if RTO was paired with getting rid of those spaces that no one except management liked.


Since moving to remote, I realized that I was good at hiding my lack of work in the office by socializing with folks to an excessive amount. Then occasionally, I would find a high priority - but low effort - problem to solve which would make up for my lack of work.

Whereas now, I find it a challenge to produce a consistent amount of work. So I have been practicing this and controlling my environment to help with it. Also my social time is now intentional, so I am not constantly pulling others from their work.

So for some, I imagine remote work is beneficial for productivity as well! Just requires some time to adjust and learn how to be better.


Great American Insurance has a hateful policy of denying WFH...if there are kids in the home.


Good thing then that you're not allowed to ask about kids.


How do you get them registered as dependents on the insurance plan then? heh


Woa, your employer has access to that? I'm in Canada and I thought they don't here, but I'm not sure.


I'm in Canada and I cannot register dependents with my insurance directly, I need to do paperwork with HR


Interesting, I think I was wrong then.


There may be a difference between extended health care benefits and public health care? But the root comment is about a private insurer so I think the distinction is moot.


Oh in my case no, the insurance company is where I register that. But I thought that's what we were talking about since the original comment was about Great American Insurance (it occurs to me maybe they meant _as an employee of Great American Insurance_???) lol


You are allowed to work from home if no kids will be there while you are working. I think they mandate bras in the dress code as well.


I agree that WFH is good for families, but as soon as politicians and commentators start saying it out loud it'll be used to justify hiring discrimination against hiring parents because they'll have divided focus.


Lol'd when he described his ideal situation, cause that's exactly how I live - working remotely and living next to a lake.

It is awesome.


yes you are right Remote work is good but some people take for grant it they don't work properly even not attending meetings properly. But remote work is good




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: