Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

i don't think his intention is to move content, but rather just to make that content more easily accessible and visible to mobile users.

the problem with mobile websites is that they have to compete with the app store. if an iphone user wants a train schedule, are they more likely to open up a browser and search google for "train schedule iphone" and scroll around clicking on random sites? or would they just open the app store, search for "train schedule" and easily see all available apps, ranked and reviewed, easily added to their home screen with a single click?

i run such a mobile website for metra trains (http://metra.jcs.org/) but because i have no native app in the ios or android stores, it doesn't see much traffic. i've thought about developing an app that just embeds a browser and goes to the site, just so it can be listed in the app store.

apple does in fact have a listing of mobile web apps at https://www.apple.com/webapps/ but i doubt most iphone owners even know it exists. it's also not very easy to use from mobile devices, strangely enough.



When I want to look at the train schedule, I just touch the bookmark on my home screen, which takes me to the web page with the schedule.


And if every iPhone user understands bookmarks as well as you do, perhaps this service will fail.

But I hear rumors that a lot of App Store apps get lots of downloads, even if they're nothing but links to existing web sites wrapped in an app shell. Many customers don't understand bookmarks.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: