Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Russian-speaking citizens don't really want to study Russian as an "elective subject". They want to study in Russian. You have confirmed that it was getting no longer possible.

That's like forcing all Canadians to be only taught in French and subsequently losing Vancouver to the US.

So you have just confirmed everything that propaganda was talking about and were quite efficient at that.



The thread started by whimsicalism stating that Russian was banned in Ukraine, and I replied that it had a status similar to French or German in the US.

Nobody has ever banned a language by allowing printing in it, allowing grades up to 4 to be taught in it, allowing secondary schools to teach it as a subject, and allowing private groups to continue teaching it as a primary language.


The correct comparison is Spanish - I wonder what's the status of education in Spanish in thr US.

But more correct case in point is Belgium. If Belgium tried to force education to be in Dutch exclusively, there would very soon be no Belgium.

> allowing grades up to 4 to be taught in it,

"Banning grades after 4 from being taught in Russian" - I did it for you

All 30 years of Ukraine's independence they were seeing new limitations to the use of Russian, every year. Some of these are listed in comments.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: