Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From my experience in the media industry some producers/higher ups like making arbitrary changes to a work/show/whatever just so they can say they had an impact, or to say that they made that change at the end, most of the time it ends up making the final product worst.



I've used that trick on Fortune 500 CEO's many times. Almost never had any of my designs changed beyond whatever "duck" I put in.


Every once in awhile they fall in love with the duck, and it becomes the center piece - so it's not without risks!


There is a joke among audio engineers that they need to have a button specifically for this - I forget the exact name used ( I have heard several) but essentially it is a button that does nothing. The Exec or higher up asks for a very small tweak and the engineer obliges (by pressing the button) and then plays it back again. Nothing has changed but the Exec feels satisfied.


There's a HN classic for that: "Just remove the duck"

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9137736


This reminds me of stories about directors intentionally putting ridiculously over-the-top violent or sexual scenes in their already quite violent or sexual movies for the rating board to focus on, and getting a PG-13 rating (instead of an R or NC-17) by removing it.


Oh wow – I remember battle chess! I played it as a kid and loved it. Thanks for sharing this.


Happens in music. Producer will make arbitrary change and now they are a co-writer and qualify for royalties.


Not quite the same thing. This phenomenon is how meddling managers like to make a decision simply so they feel useful, not for any material gain.

What you’re describing is “taking credit”.


The Black Keys talked about this on Joe Rogan's podcast. Pat Carney, the drummer, calls it "the guy with a degree from Pepperdine who wants to tweak the high hat."


When I was in the biz we called it "write a word, take a third."


I've been annoyed at this but some of the changes are based on focus groups and other data suggesting that it will appeal to a larger portion of the local public when changed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: