Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


> where I'm supposed to talk to some HR girl instead of an equal

There's no need to be demeaning to people (not just "girls") who work in HR.


>I cancel all interviews where I'm supposed to talk to some HR girl instead of an equal

Seems like those interviews are doing their job then if they screen you out


Ha! One could think that the psychological screening is meaningless... until you are involved in hiring people. Of course, 95% candidates will pass, otherwise humanity would be doomed


I'm wary of engaging with this comment at all but... How are you so sure it was "some psycho test" rather than, say, their actual availability?


> What are your strengths and weaknesses,.. hey what is this a psychological scan?

That's exactly what it is, and it's important. It's not helpful over the long run if we hire someone who can crank out good code, but their mindset negatively infects the rest of the team, causing morale to drop and people to leave.

I give technical interviews, but I'm also evaluating soft skills while I do it. I would rather have a team with ok-to-good technical skills, than a team with a rockstar prima donna who sabotages the cohesiveness of the whole.


>it's important

Very little empirical evidence supports it, despite people parroting how "useful" it is. You're also teaching people to BS about themselves to get a job, perverting the entire thing.

If you want to psychologically analyze people, use a method which is actually supported empirically instead of the "do what every other pseudo-psychologist does" method. Big 5, for one, actually has some empirical evidence supporting it, but is barely ever used.

On the other hand, if you can actually figure people out in an hour under a single set of constraints, somehow being able to extrapolate that to the work environment as a whole, while also trying to put the work environment in a much better light than it actually is: quit your IT job now and make millions selling books.


Building software mostly requires working in teams though. If you want to go it alone as a contractor there's no need to be applying to HR depts

I mean, forgive me for stating the obvious, but they're not trying to make you come out of your shell because they want a friend to talk to.


thank you for speaking up




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: