Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
macOS 12.3 solves 2019 MacBook Pro 16“ overheating issue with external monitors
7 points by seam_carver on March 18, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 4 comments
For context, there’s a 231+ page thread on MacRumors of people complaining and troubleshooting the issue of excessive heat/fan noise when using specifically their 2019 16" MBP’s while plugged into external monitors of certain resolutions/frame rates, even at idle with nothing running.

The root cause was a bad GPU driver. Throughout the years, people have tried various workarounds, like using the laptop in clamshell mode, force enabling HiDPI mode for the monitor, using Monterey's Low Power Mode. (Some solutions of which I discovered myself.)

But now, this issue is fixed by Monday's macOS update, no workaround needed! People have been celebrating in the aforementioned MacRumors thread. In Big Sur and earlier, idle GPU usage was ~18W. This is insane power draw at idle. In earlier version of Monterey, ~14W. Using low power mode, ~6W, but this required compromises like disabling CPU turboboost which may matter for some workflows.

But now in Monterey 12.3, it's now ~6W straight up, no compromises or workarounds or fiddling with settings needed!

No longer do I have to deal with loud fans at idle with just a monitor attached or extremely loud fans when doing simple stuff like zoom calls and screen shares. So if you have this model MacBook, go update to 12.3!



Nice! About time they fixed something, amirite? I've noticed this behavior in some cases myself, but I always thought it was due to my using an external GPU (Razer Core X I think, with a Vega 56)...

Speaking of, have you ever had a situation where, without warning and totally random - even while idle - your Mac just goes APESHIT with the fans, instantly clicks into super overdrive cooling wise, and then shuts down? Because I've had that in the past and if this fixes that...well...I may do the happy dance. And I hate dancing.


Yup! Took them long enough, after everyone already gave up and replaced them with M1!

Also, if you have this issue with an external GPU, something else is going on, since in that case the GPU inside the Mac isn't being used and generating heat.

And no, haven't had that kind of extreme issue. Maybe you have dust?


DP 1.4 support is broken again, maybe that's why?


I was using HDMI, don't think it's related.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: