Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

VS Code is not a replacement for an IDE. While I only know IntelliJ, I assume VS must be similar. In short, VS Code is a replacement for Notepad, and not for an IDE. It's not as well integrated, not as thought-out and capable. The only thing that saves it IMO is the remote server mode.


VS is my daily driver and I absolutely agree that VS Code doesn’t come anywhere close to a fully fledged IDE like VS.

But VS Code is far more just a text editor and that you can run and debug many languages in it in my opinion means it meets the criteria of an IDE.

If I was forced to switch from VS to VS Code I would be miserable and feel handicapped, but infinitely more productive than just having a text editor and the dotnet CLI.

So VS Code is absolutely a “replacement” for VS, but only for a poor man with a very limited set of required features.

All the above being said, I don’t ever see VS Code truly replacing VS, but it’s a competent IDE considering its both cross platform and free as in beer.


Maybe it feels like an IDE for people used to text editors like VIM. It's probably middle ground between a text editor and an IDE.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: