Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Since I don't find the idea of yuppies buying yuppies coffees very interesting I decided to mix things up a bit.

OP/Sam, I understand that you believe there are worse problems in the world. I have no doubt that you are correct. However, this does not change the fact that your own social experiment amounts to you taking advantage of the good will of those who contributed to the Starbucks card by stealing from them. Contributing the money to a charity afterwards does not change this fact.

You are not Robin Hood stealing from a corrupt Sheriff of Nottingham. So please don't act like it.



Robin Hood is all about stealing to the rich to give to the poor and in that respect, I think Sam is right on.


Robin Hood is actually all about robbing from corrupt oppressors and protecting the oppressed. There are tales where the people he protects are fairly well off, and he regularly interacts with people of medium to high status without any intent of robbing them.

Nothing in the tales of Robin Hood suggests he would rob an honest rich man.


Okay, but I'm not rich and Sam stole from me.


No, you donated to a commons. You expected it to be used in a specific way, but it was used in a different way.


He donated to a fund that was intended to be used in a very particular way. Sam Odio took money from that fund, used it otherwise, and insulted everyone who placed money into it.

Sam Odio stole from the fund, Sam Odio stole from zacharycohn.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: