Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is blatant capitalist propaganda. Basic access to things like housing and education make for a tangibly wealthier society. Every dollar we invest in preschool education, for example, nets out $6 in terms of return throughout the course of the child's life.[1]

The nation continues on its "high variance" trajectory because it is structurally incapable of acting democratically. Two of the four major deliberative bodies are anti-democratic. The Senate is elected in extreme disproportion and the Supreme Court is ridiculous 9 unelected seniors deciding outcomes for an entire country.

It was set up this way intentionally, to entrench and structurally favor wealthy Southern slaveholders and established Northern merchants that traded on their commodities.

1. https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2016/12/12/504867570/how-inv...



> This is blatant capitalist propaganda.

Oh indeed, and you're salty about it because you know that you're losing because you simply cannot deliver equivalent results.

dang, if you're reading this, I'll take my smack on the nose with a rolled-up newspaper now.


Delivering results for whom exactly? Look outside and you'll see homelessness rising and storefronts closing.

The entire failed national pandemic response is due to the perverse incentives of our system.

Five hundred thousand Americans (and counting) are dead because we couldn't close the economy for a couple months and pay people to stay home.


Far be it from me to argue that the United States is competently administered compared to, e.g., a successful firm.

It's still a global superpower for a reason, and that reason is not "communism will totally work this time"


Of course you can't argue with the substance of my point. All it goes to show is how willing you are to write off half a million dead Americans for continued profits and power. Power to do what, exactly?

It's not just the communist countries like Vietnam and Cuba, even capitalist countries with newly minted leftist leadership like South Korea, have weathered this crisis with orders of magnitude less loss.

The systems for rending economic value from the value of human life are deeply entrenched here. Always have been[1]. That we can divorce the success of firms from the success of the people providing the value on the ground doing the work is a testament to it.

It doesn't make us awesome, it makes us abhorrent. The people that you claim "soar" are not randomly distributed, they are frequently born into favorable economic situations that allow them to develop the talents that make them super rich. In our lifetimes those islands of stability have degraded entirely in the service of ensuring the super rich can get even richer.

1. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/08/14/magazine/1619...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: