Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Yes, you can[1]. It will even sync automatically with whatever git repo you store the settings in.

No you cannot. Note I was being very precise in my wording. While you can now export your Jetbrains IDE's config as a git repo (or zip file) of text files, you still cannot configure the IDE through text files (like in SublimeText) because 1) the text files' format is not documented anywhere and likely to change in the future without further warning and 2) Jetbrains also writes changes to the git repo automatically. I want to be in control of my config, though. (Sure, I could roll back any changes but I think that's very sub-optimal solution.)

> This is a problem with relying on the IDE host to also be the host of your applications. Your repo should contain build settings, not your IDE.

Well, yes, we do have all our build scripts etc. in our repo but that doesn't keep people (myself included) from running and debugging things from within their IDE because it's a lot more comfortable.



> Note I was being very precise in my wording

I noted your wording, which was not as narrow as your intention. You just said you wanted deterministic, text-based config, which JetBrains has.

I've used VS Code's text-file config, before there was a GUI for most of the config options, and I actually found it to be pretty frustrating. A good GUI is a lot better than editing text, even with the IDE helping you stay within the schema.

JetBrains IDE's probably fail the worst in that regard, I agree; but once you have a config you like, it's easy to keep it consistent.

> but that doesn't keep people (myself included) from running and debugging things from within their IDE because it's a lot more comfortable

Again, these aren't mutually exclusive. You can run/debug code in a Docker container[1][2]. The IDE experience is exactly the same (click the Debug icon or use the shortcut, set breakpoints, whatever), it's just that the VM is running your code instead of your dev environment.

1. Typescript - https://blog.entrostat.com/debugging-a-typescript-project-in...

2. Python - https://www.jetbrains.com/help/pycharm/using-docker-as-a-rem...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: