Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Spectre, meltdown reduce Intel's performance by quite a lot. https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=linux-41...

And seeing how AMD is already a faster and better CPU in general (I mean the latest AMD Ryzen 3000 vs Intel 9000 series, at time of writing this), I'm not sure what about that needs citation?



Been seeing ryzen tear into intel cpus in terms of output / power .. its ridiculous. AMD drew a straight on the river, truly awe inspiring and refreshing.


If you're going to comment on an article about a performance focused SIMD JSON parser and say a chip without AVX512 is faster than one with it, you're going to need to provide some proof.


Pretty sure the op was asking for a citation specifically about aws nodes. Should be simple enough to take a test workload on Intel vs amd nodes and measure things (besides "safety" which is too nebulous to measure). Consumer chips aren't entirely relevant.


I'm pretty sure I linked server chip comparison. And the same guys that design consumer chips, design server, so there will be a lot of "cross-pollination" between architectures. We definitely see that a lot of Intel consumer and server grade is hit with similar bugs.

Safety can be roughly estimated by a number of critical vulnerabilities. Most have hit Intel, some being Intel specific bugs.


But the mitigations in AWS' VM monitor might be a fixed cost--i.e. not disabled on AMD architectures or otherwise not disadvantaging Intel. For example, they might use techniques like page coloring as an alternative to cache flushing and prediction suppression, which wouldn't disadvantage Intel, might not impose any significant overhead at all, and might even improve performance in shared hosting environments.

Alternatively, maybe their support for AMD is nascent and optimizations for Intel absent on AMD.

There's really no substitute for benchmarking AWS' actual offerings.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: