Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's not a real cryptocurrency if someone can shut the whole network down.


If you read the article, you would see that just the node with signs the transaction as legit was taken offline for the moment while they work on it.

Your definition of crypto currency and decentralised currency is conflated too.


You just proved OP's point. Cryptocurrency which isn't seriously decentralized is pretty pointless - you might as well just go back Wells Fargo and an Oracle DB.


The very existence of "the node" makes it not a cryptocurrency


It's a cryptocurrency, just not decentralized.


I would have agreed with you but after checking wikipedia, decentralization is actually the first requirement for it to be called a cryptocurrency.

> 1. The system does not require a central authority, its state is maintained through distributed consensus.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptocurrency#Formal_definiti...

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cryptocurrency


The codebase doesn't require a central authority, but in practice all keys for top level auth are held by the same entity.


Sort of like how society doesn't require me to not be a billionaire, but in practise i'm not a billionaire.

Code not deployed and probably never tested (perhaps never even worked) does not count.


That makes it a PayPal not a crypto-currency


Decentralization is one of the defining traits of a cryptocurrency. It's like saying a car is an airplane, but without wings. It just doesn't make sense.


Actually it does - even a centrally run crypto has verifiability and other properties that naive "central-database" system does not.

Furthermore, you can run like a consortium style crypto currency, where its jointly controlled by multiple organisations.


I doubt it. What properties specificly?

Hell even bitcoin doesn't have a great notion of verifability (verify what? No double spending? Lets hope your opponent doesn't control 33% of the hash power.). Central-db systems can issue recipts (like humans have been doing for thousands of years). Centralized cyrptocurrencies basically offer the same protection at best and much less at worse.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: