Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It starts with a horrifying dive into '60s Revolutionary China, then veers off into an extremely surreal and nerdy anime plot, and proceeds on a very cool and foreboding sci-fi arc (I think; I don't remember how much of the sci-fi it has vs. how much of it is in the two sequels).


That's a good way to put it. The novel series manages to have 1) brilliant and highly imaginative set-piece sci-fi events 2) ruminations on the possibly dark nature of humanity in space 3) amateurish characters - save two or three 4) universal-scale scope 5) awareness of just 6 countries in the world : all at the same time.


And a lame ending compared to the rest of the trilogy. It's like in the last 50 pages he run out of ideas.


In his defense, he explored quite a bit.

I really had kind of hoped to get a glimpse into what he'd have come up with for if the universe restarted.


Ending is hard, and when it comes to sci-fi series it empirically looks impossible: I can't remember a single one whose end wasn't disappointing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: