Results clearly indicate that isn't the case. EG the 2000 and 2016 elections.
The level of cognitive dissonance the public has about politics is the most disheartening part of the whole burning shit show. Remember America; It's your own fault if he beats you, you made him do it.
How do those two elections show that? Because of the popular vote in the presidential elections? Don't forget that our representatives (the people who actually are responsible for legislation) are voted in directly. No electoral college for them.
It is also possible that the majority doesn't feel (read: vote) the same way about these issues as you. Would that mean that the system is flawed?