Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Maybe in 1945. A nazi poses no threat, imminent or otherwise, if they are just spouting bullshit on a street.


A nazi posed no threat when they were being accepted in Germany, until suddenly they had enough power to start killing people with no consequence. Anyone who is currently a Nazi, KKK member, etc knows that is the inevitable conclusion to following their ideas down the rabbit hole and will be complacent if they ever think they can get away with it. The murderer in Charlottesville spent the day being hyped up before plowing his car into dozens of people.


Nazism is discredited. There is essentially no chance that Nazism will take over America.

There is a chance, may a certainty that some of these Nazis will hurt people. But people of all political strips do that. You'd have to punch environmentalists because of eco-terrorists, etc.

Attacking people because their ideas are dangerous is a mockery of free speech.

Even if you don't care about freedom of speech, escalating violence is still a stupid choice. The Nazis will punch back harder, as they've already done. Violence begets violence.


I take it you are a big fan of mccarthyism?


> A nazi posed no threat when they were being accepted in Germany, until suddenly

That is not historically accurate at all. The nazis rose to a measure of acceptance in Germany in large part because of political violence on the left.


> The nazis rose to a measure of acceptance in Germany in large part because of political violence on the left.

That’s inaccurate. It's true that a background level of political violence across the spectrum that started prior to the Nazis even existing was a factor in both the development of Nazi ideology and methods and in why a solid anti-Nazi coalition was unable to form (and perhaps also a factor in why the ban on the Nazis based in part on their political violence was unable to be maintained politically), but this wasn't uniquely a characteristic of the left.


> The nazis rose to a measure of acceptance in Germany in large part because of political violence on the left.

Yeah, that's just not correct.


> A nazi poses no threat, imminent or otherwise, if they are just spouting bullshit on a street.

“No threat” is overstated, but certainly not the kind of imminent threat that justifies a violent response.

Conversely, political violence by non-Nazis, historically, is a major factor in politically enabling Nazis.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: