Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not really HN, but OK.

P.S. I have previously discussed my dating catch-22 with other people who had/have Chordoma; it was not pleasant. Most are deeply offended so I no longer bring it up with them. If someone from that world happens to read this post and is offended or saddened, I’m sorry. It’s not my intention.

What is there to be offended about? It's not the author's fault you're going to die.



Most people do not restrain themselves; they consider it harsh judgement.

I debated whether or not it was HN material. In the end, I thought is was an interesting moral question, therefore it would be interesting to HN.


It was a good article. When I think about it from an outsider's perspective, I totally agree with your argument. What you say is definitely the most rational possibility.

If I think about it from the perspective, "If I could have the girl of my dreams right now, would I turn her down because she's going to die in a year?", the answer is no. That's because it's irrational; I have never seen anyone close to me die, so I don't know what to expect. Might as well be blissfully ignorant, then be sad for a few days/weeks, then move on.

Maybe.


It was a good article. When I think about it from an outsider's perspective, I totally agree with your argument. What you say is definitely the most rational possibility.

If I think about it from the perspective, "If I could have the girl of my dreams right now, would I turn her down because she's going to die in a year?", the answer is no. That's because it's irrational; I have never seen anyone close to me die, so I don't know what to expect. Might as well be blissfully ignorant, then be sad for a few days/weeks, then move on.

Maybe.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: