Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's an unhelpful answer and misleading.

React native has a LOT of attention. It has a lot of support. BUT as of this writing if you are developing in corporate IT (meaning possibly running windows 7 systems) you actually CANNOT run react-native tools on windows easily.

I'm currently building an ionic project because I needed a cross-plat mobile app and work with a mix of OSX and windows 7 machines.

Now that said, windows 10 systems with the ubuntu emulator should be able to emulate all the calls you need to run react native on windows machines.

HOWEVER windows 10 bash has not yet implemented all 350 linux system calls (https://wpdev.uservoice.com/forums/266908-command-prompt-con...) and there is no guarantee that is bug free.

I'd hate to be 2 months into development to find there are deep internals that block me from using a critical feature.

None of this is to say Xamarin doesn't have its own baggage. The reason I web with cordova/ionic was for the good of the other developers on my team (html+css+javascript over C#) and, at the time, the additional cost of the Xamarin licenses.

I would have given XAMARIN a much closer look if it were bundled with a Visual Studio license, and all things considered, if I were looking today, it might beat out React Native.

That said, I do agree that react-native MAY be the way forward in the next generation, but, Xamarin does have more than enough upside to make it a reasonable contender.



> BUT as of this writing if you are developing in corporate IT (meaning possibly running windows 7 systems) you actually CANNOT run react-native tools on windows easily.

Eh? I use React Native on Windows. Works just fine. It's also very easy to install. Maybe you didn't try recently?


Few months. But we all know a lot has happened in the last few months.

The f8 conference has happened since plus all these windows announcements.

Did you install on a windows 7 machine?


Yup Windows 7.


Have you tried NativeScript on Windows?


Haven't even heard of it! That looks really interesting. I'll add that to the list of candidates at the start of my next crossplat mobile app.


Don't bother.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: