Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What does one even use that much FPGA for? Any organization that could afford that could probably afford making an ASIC of comparable or better performance.

...That said, that's crazy impressive.



One example that comes to mind is data analysis for radioastronomy. With arrays of radiotelescopes, as far as I understand it, you will downconvert an incoming frequency band spanning a few GHz, which gives you a few GByte/sec of data for each antenna. Then you might have an array of 50 telescopes (the ALMA array is planned to have 50 or so, I think).

This stream of maybe a TByte/sec of data will then be filtered and decimated/downconverted in real time by racks full of DSP/FPGA boards. Here's a picture of one board used for an Australian facility:

http://www.atnf.csiro.au/news/newsletter/oct06/CABB.htm

5x Virtex II XC2VP50 (23,616 slices, 2 PowerPC CPU blocks, $1700 each)

5x Virtex 4 XC4VSX55 (15,360 slices, $1300 each)

Yes, an ASIC might be more energy efficient and could be made faster, but FPGAs give you the flexibility to adapt your algorithms and filter topologies. And an ASIC run might cost you half a million dollars whereas with FPGAs you only spend ~15'000$/board.


Funnily enough, one of the uses of these monster FPGAs is for simulating and prototyping ASIC designs.


If you're going to build and sell a hundred of £20000 devices, for some very specific market niche, it is still more justified than building hundreds of thousands of £10 devices and only selling one hundred.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: