The issue was that along with...
- calling the entire industry scum to pull in attention
- going out of his way to flam Squidoo as a spam site until he got them penalized
- creating something far spammier and far more automated than Squidoo
When you add it all together it is pretty bad.
Maybe not quite at the Matt Cutts level...but nonetheless way way way up there...like at least in the top 0.01%.
The issue was that along with...
- calling the entire industry scum to pull in attention
- going out of his way to flam Squidoo as a spam site until he got them penalized
- creating something far spammier and far more automated than Squidoo
When you add it all together it is pretty bad.