Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I am sure this was not your intention or meaning, but please be aware that it is virtually impossible for a non-native speaker to write perfect English. English is a language you have to intuit. In contrast to other languages, it has very few fixed rules. Writing elegantly in English is most certainly an art form.

Of course, writing good science is hard enough for native speakers. It is very difficult for the vast majority of people on the planet - no matter how good their research.

And just so we are clear: Not everyone can afford professional editing services at every point in their career.

We meet in English under the premise that it allows for universal communication. In this, we accept that English natives are almost infinitely more privileged in writing, speaking, conferencing and networking. We also have to accept that the level of English proficiency varies, and - especially English - is easy to learn and so difficult to master.



> it is virtually impossible for a non-native speaker to write perfect English. English is a language you have to intuit. In contrast to other languages, it has very few fixed rules. Writing elegantly in English is most certainly an art form.

Learning to write well in any language is difficult. English is not exceptional as a language. Its influence in economic activity is what gives it prevalance.


I think you missed this part of the comment to which you were replying:

> And no, I am not talking about cases where the author is writing in a non-native language.


Oh that is certainly not true. English is a fuzzy merchant pidgin but that's precisely what makes it almost trivial to learn, plus the CIA in it's infinite wisdom has seen it fit to encourage production of deluge of entertainment media that make immersing oneself in English content easier than any other language.


I think at least skimming some edition of the

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Chicago_Manual_of_Style

and some of what is available under

[2] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=military+writing+guide

would be useful for american english and technical writing.


The issue here is not bad English in the sense you'd expect from a learner or someone who just isn't fluent. Nobody minds that, although you say not everyone can afford professional editing services: that's what journals are theoretically for!

The actual problem here is fluent English that is written in a totally bizarre style only found in academic papers. I've found that academic-ese is less of a problem in good computer science papers (like the one this article is about), but it crops up in some fields a lot. A trivial and not very important example is the way minor things are routinely described as "novel", a word you rarely find in everyday English, but in the research literature everything is "novel".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: