Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> In recent years, motors have started to be designed for the non sinusoidal waveforms that come out of chopper power supplies.

From what i remember, square waves are better for a motor. Thinking about it i see no benefit of it being sine (*with many poles, that is, as a square would shake the mechanical parts too much otherwise).

The trams here have 3-phase engines.



I think you're right. The thing with three phase motors is that you have a rotating magnetic field, which necessitates sinusoidal currents.


Depends on the windings. Synchronous motors have had windings designed for sq. wave drive for many years now, prominently for stepper, servo and BLDC motors. These still use some filtering to reduce the insulation stresses.


They use square waves for them because squares are much easier to make, not because they work better.

Good driver chips (e.g. https://www.trinamic.com/) still synthesize sinusoidal-like waves for these motors. It reduces noise and power consumption.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: